Guide + connection service — not a deck builderNational methods authority · your town is asked on the request form

Method Deck
The Method Plates — how a deck is actually put together, stage by stage

Stage 3 · Decking materials compared

Materials: every board is a trade, and the brochure only lists one side

The honest comparison is not wood versus composite. It is five materials, each with a failure mode it is famous for and a virtue the others cannot match. Choose the failure mode you can live with.

Deck board profilesCross-section profiles of four deck boards: solid wood, grooved composite, capped polymer, and tropical hardwood, showing thickness and edge differences. Wood, solidComposite, groovedCapped polymerHardwood Actual thickness: a nominal 5/4 board measures about 1 in.; a 2× board about 1.5 in. Stiffness follows thickness.
Plate M-1 — Board profiles. Grooves are for hidden clips, not decoration; solid-edge boards are still required at picture-frame borders and stair treads.

Pressure-treated pine

Cheapest to buy, stiffest feel per dollar, coolest underfoot of the synthetics' rivals. The trades: it checks, cups and twists as it dries (buy it as dry as you can find, fasten it promptly); it needs stain or sealer every 1–3 years to keep its looks and slow surface checking; and its preservative dictates hot-dip galvanized or stainless hardware. Realistic surface life with maintenance: 15–20 years; the frame beneath it, also treated, commonly outlasts two surfaces.

Cedar (and redwood)

Naturally rot-resistant heartwood, light, stable, pleasant barefoot. Softer than pine — it dents — and the sapwood boards mixed into a lift have little of the heartwood's resistance, so grade selection matters more than species name. Costs sit between treated pine and composite. Maintenance is for colour as much as protection: left alone it silvers, which some owners choose deliberately. Fasteners: stainless or high-grade coated — cedar extractives stain and corrode lesser metal.

Wood-plastic composite

Named factually: the established families are Trex, TimberTech's composite lines, Fiberon and Deckorators, among others. No rot, no splinters, no staining calendar. The realities the ads skip: dark colours in full sun reach temperatures bare feet refuse (lighter colours and shade are functional choices, not just aesthetic); early fade is real — boards weather toward a lighter, stable tone in the first seasons, so a replacement board years later will not match until it weathers too; the material expands and contracts lengthwise with temperature, which is why end gaps are set by the temperature on install day; and it is less stiff than wood, hence the 16-inch (often 12-inch) joist spacing. Warranties of 25 years typically cover fade-and-stain and structural defects — read what “fade” is defined as before counting on it.

Capped polymer / PVC

TimberTech AZEK and similar all-polymer boards: no wood fibre at all, the lightest and most moisture-indifferent option, top of the price range. Cooler than many composites in comparable colours, still warm in dark tones. Movement with temperature is the largest of any material here — installers who treat it like wood produce buckled picture frames. It is the rational choice for docks, pool surrounds and ground-hugging decks where ventilation is poor.

Tropical hardwoods (ipe and relatives)

Ipe is roughly three times as hard as oak, naturally oily, and genuinely capable of 25–40 years of surface life. It is also heavy, hard on blades, requires pre-drilling every fastener hole, wants stainless hardware only, and silvers without regular oil — a maintenance commitment most buyers underestimate. End-seal cut ends, allow for its sourcing questions (ask for FSC-certified or verified legal supply), and budget the labour honestly: hardwood decks cost in installation what composite decks cost in material.

The comparison, in one table

MaterialInstalled cost tendencyHeat in sunMaintenanceRealistic surface life
Pressure-treated pineLowestLowStain/sealer every 1–3 yrs15–20 yrs
CedarLow–midLowClean + finish every 2–3 yrs15–25 yrs
CompositeMid–highHigh in dark coloursWash yearly; no staining25 yrs (warranted class)
Capped polymerHighest of the syntheticsModerate–highWash yearly30–50 yr warranty class
Ipe / tropical hardwoodHigh (labour-heavy)ModerateOil yearly to hold colour25–40 yrs

Installed-cost tendencies are relative planning guidance; the cost ledger prints the per-square-foot ranges this site computes from.